There is the utopian ideals expressed in gene roddenberrys vision of star trek. Star wars dystopic vision is far more realistic and prepares our. Truthfully, the debate is substantiated, but at this point, it is a little old. If its a question of taste ie do you like star wars more than star trek, debate becomes impossible. Star trek, star wars and isaac asimov run deep at nasa as its people.
But these two universes are actually very different, and i have a. Star wars and star trek are both science based and involve space travel and aliens. The force awakens and this summers star trek beyond and then looked at what other. The essential difference between star wars and star trek. To find out at the end of return of the jedi that there is some good in darth vader and that there is some evil in luke skywalker was a really powerful theme for me when i was a. And other galaxyshaking enigmas kindle edition by forbeck, matt. Star wars is a massive outwardly adventure while star trek aspires to use science fiction as a metaphor for our reality. The technology in star trek is supposed to be at least loosely grounded in science or potential future science, rather than supernatural forces or magic. Dec 15, 2016 the location intelligence company looked at users who checked in to screenings of last years star wars. Star trek vs star wars difference and comparison diffen. Kirk, captain of the starship uss enterprise, and its crew, which included spock, leonard mccoy. Star wars revenge of the sith book to movie comparison. Could a jedi knight use his light saber to deflect a beam from a phaser. Star trek has a sense of wonder, a sense of hope even in its darker iterations, like deep space nine or star trek into darkness.
The system debuted on nasas technologytesting 1998 deep space 1 mission and was almost saddled with the acronym nstar. Many derivative star wars works have been produced in conjunction with, between, and after. Yet, while that is mostly between parent corporations, the rivalry between star wars and star trek is more primal. Star wars, meanwhile, seems to focus on hope for one hero, or. It will be the subject of the documentary series slugfest by avengers directors joe and anthony russo on quibi. Star trek and star wars are american media franchises which present alternative scenarios of. The animated series commenced in 1973 based directly on the original series but lasted only two seasons with a combined total of 22 episodes. Hilarious almost as hilarious as star trek five, we dont speak of the star trek movies thats weird because it seems like all you do is talk to your simple shoot him up. Question about the firepower of star trek vs star wars. They love to include largerthanlife creatures that make audiences gasp and revel over. His latest work includes dungeonlogy, the star wars. Star wars has better tech, but star trek has the q continuum, which overpowers the force easily.
And other galaxyshaking enigmas by matt forbeck available from rakuten kobo. The series depicts the adventures of various characters a long time ago in a galaxy far, far away. Ever since princess leias starship hove into sight on the silver screen, fans of star wars and star trek have been debating these questions. Question about the firepower of star trek vs star wars canon question im watching star wars for the first time and theres a line in a new hope about how the entire star fleet doesnt have enough power to destroy a planet, however, in star trek the romulans and cardassians were able to destroy the crust of the founders homeworld in 1 volley. However the follow through on this book lacks the basic understanding of the key difference between the franchises, star wars is a movie franchise while star trek is a series of tv shows. The main reason people confuse the two is the common first part of the title.
Everyday low prices and free delivery on eligible orders. May 04, 2017 for decades fans of star wars and star trek have debated over which one is better. And other galaxyshaking enigmas by forbeck, matt isbn. With the subsequent publication of novels, comics, animated series, toys and feature films, star trek grew into a popular media franchise.
But unlike those timeless questions this one really does seem to have a compelling answer. Or, more specifically, the light sabers were drawn and the phasers were set to kill. That being said, is this quote from star wars or star trek. See more ideas about star trek, trek and star wars.
Star trek is scifi because it is steeped in scientific theory warp drive, subspace, antimatter, etc. For over 40 years now, fans of both star trek and star wars have been arguing about which movie franchise is better. Here are 19 reasons why star wars is better than star trek. Matt forbeck is an awardwinning and new york times bestselling author and game designer. What are the main differences between star trek and star. Chapter 12 planetstheres always just one more to explore. On a given night, whose characters would you like to explore the universe with. It is comparable to a military movie or a medieval movie about storming castles and winning battles. Difference between star trek and star wars compare the. Star trek vs star wars star trek and star wars are two headers that are often confused as similar in content when strictly speaking they are different from each other. While star wars has many similar elements, it also includes things that could never exsist in the star trek universe i. He was portrayed by jeffrey hunter in the original star trek pilot episode, the cage, as captain of the uss enterprise.
Now, side by side, they can line up aliens, technology, story points, weaponry, and heroes from the two great science fictionfantasy stories of our age. Star trek, originally a tv series, is a space western science fiction that centers around a crew who serves in starfleet, a spacebased peacekeeping and humanitarian armada. Star trek was introduced as a liveaction television series in 1966 that lasted three years. Star trek has phasers as well as a dedication to higher sensibilities. Star wars is bigger than ever, and were celebrating 50 years of star trek. The difference between star trek and star wars articles. Captain christopher chris pike is a character in the star trek science fiction franchise. Star wars measure destroy a planet in the same way that they measure destroy anything. There is the swashbuckling popcorn glory that stirs an imagination that is star wars. Star trek and the impossibility in deciding which science fiction story is.
There are more, but i have some actual work to attend to, so please feel free to sound off in the comments below. Star wars, originally a trilogy, is a space opera fantasy franchise set in the dis. To the casual observer, star trek and star wars look a lot alike, beyond the obvious similarity between their names. May 18, 2020 star wars vs star trek pictures and artwork.
Han solo and the jedi take on captain kirk and the federation in a scifi clash of titans to once again try to settle the longrunning debate. Both star wars and star trek have the most recognized starships in the world, from the xwing to the enterprise 123. First, star wars vs star trek normally means could the empire kick the federations ass. Star trek lures you into a false sense of positivity that the world can be a utopia and recent events have proven it cannot. The difference between star trek and star wars if you remove what you think is the source of conflict from a story and there is still trouble, you havent properly identified the source of conflict. Sep 18, 2010 footage from star trek 2009 star trek first contact star trek generations star trek nemesis star wars a new hope star wars the empire strikes back star wars return of the jedi star wars revenge. With the q star trek wins, otherwise star wars wins. Download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets.
Nasas star trek dreams arent so crazy after all cnet. Star trek could the empire kick the federations ass. Discover unique things to do, places to eat, and sights to see in the best destinations around the world with bring me. There are a number of differences between the book and the movie but we are just going to focus on one category now, the feelings and inside information that is not seen in the movie. With plenty of opinions on either side the internet often turns into a battleground on this subject. Tatooine and coruscant, vulcan and romulus, and outward 7. They get lost in isaac asimov books, watch the expanse and nerd out over star wars. Could a jedi knight use his light saber to deflect a beam f. Space 1 mission and was almost saddled with the acronym nstar. Star wars is an american epic spaceopera media franchise, centered on a film series created by george lucas that includes star wars 1977, the empire strikes back 1980, and return of the jedi 1983. This essay will look at different scenarios and suggest that different scenarios lead to different outcomes. Common belief is that star trek is science fiction, while star wars is science fantasy.
Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading star wars vs. Star wars or star trek, the fans have spoken infographic. Sep 25, 2015 another fine line between science fiction and science fact see more ideas about star wars, war and star trek. Warhammer 40k this essay is an attempt to answer the question if star trek or warhammer 40k would win in a war. I will try to keep this short, but there is just too much to cover. What are the main differences between star trek and star wars. Star trek and star wars are american media franchises which present alternative scenarios of space adventure. Dec 07, 2015 to casual moviegoers, there is not much difference between star trek, the scifi franchise that launched on television in 1966, and star wars, which debuted on movie screens in 1977. In light of the release of the first trailer for the upcoming star wars movie, the force awakens, i thought it apropos to revisit an old controversy between the star wars and star trek franchises. Star wars debuted in film, despite the novel based on the films original script having been published a year before the film itself. Stripping away the atmosphere, searing the crust even a natural event like a comet collision would classify as destroying a planet. When this pilot was rejected, hunter withdrew from the series, and pike was replaced with captain james t. He has more than thirty novels and countless games published to date.
He has designed games, and has written short fiction, comic books, novels, nonfiction, magazine articles, and computer game scripts and stories. Beyond the superficial differences of science fiction and science fantasy, both the original star wars and the 2009 version of star trek diverge in. Star wars is a story about good and evil based on eastern philosophy. The original series was released in 1966 and ran for three seasons on nbc. Free essays on compare and contrast star wars and star trek. So tell me what does count as star wars, the clone wars cartoon and the original three movies except theyre done.
I have nothing against george lucas and his galaxy far, far away. Star trek narrates the space exploration and interstellar adventures of james t. And other galaxyshaking enigmas forbeck, matt, bulloch jeremy, russ tim on. The two franchises are dominant in this setting of storytelling and have offered various forms of media productions for decades that manage billions of dollars of intellectual property, providing employment and entertainment for billions of people around the world. May 18, 2011 ever since princess leias starship hovered into sight on the silver screen, fans of star wars and star trek have been debating these questions. Star trek is a science fiction franchise created by gene roddenberry. Thanks to star trek and star wars and raymans insistence, its now known. His latest book is the world according to star wars.
912 638 1445 1112 261 1164 740 819 146 436 130 885 1228 572 1280 1134 551 1146 1494 496 1279 343 713 584 1354 159 324 500 1498 1110 1046